Molten Monkey - Best New Restaurant - 2025 - Madison Magazine

Step inside Molten Monkey, and you’ll find yourself embraced by a cozy, inviting vibe that balances the casual buzz of a neighborhood haunt with the intimate charm of a well-loved local spot. Sitting snugly on E Johnson Street, this isn’t just another pizza place — it’s a space where the rhythm of slow evenings and lively conversations blend over warm wood tones and the subtle hum of good company.

At Molten Monkey, the atmosphere feels both familiar and pleasantly unexpected, with just enough energy to keep you leaning in, whether you’re sharing a meal at one of the few bar stools or tucked away at a small table by the window. There’s a quiet joy in watching plates of Detroit-style pizza arrive — generous, perfectly crisped edges meeting bold, thoughtfully layered toppings that invite you to savor every bite, one slice at a time.

It’s not just the pies that make this place feel special. From the first pull-apart sticky “Monkey Styx” loaded with that creamy, zesty monkey sauce to the thoughtful variety of side sauces that let you experiment with every forkful, Molten Monkey honors both comfort and creativity on a plate. Salads bring a refreshing balance with simple, honest ingredients that complement the hearty fare without any fuss.

As you settle in, you’ll notice the genuine care in the service — quick to welcome, attentive but unhurried, like old friends who want you to feel at home. The evening unfolds at its own easy pace, leaving plenty of room for laughter, shared stories, and yes, that irresistible urge to have “just one more slice.”

This is a place where every visit feels like a discovery, a chance to reconnect with the simple pleasures of good food and good company in a setting that invites you to stay a little longer.